I
Want My Country Back
Like many others,
I'm one of those naïve folks who considered it extremely unlikely
that the country would elect Trump to the highest office. Yep, we
missed that prediction big time.
Although not overly
political, I do think about ideas for changes that might reduce the
odds of future outrageous election results. Here are some for
consideration.
- Ranked-choice voting (sometimes also called “instant runoff”)
“The
voting style (in Maine) will
apply to races for U.S. Senate, U.S. House, governor, state Senate
and state House.”
Imagine
if this were the way every state tallied votes for president. Lots of
folks were extremely disappointed that Bernie didn't win the
Democratic nomination. But what if it didn't matter if he won
the nomination or not – if he could've been on every state's
ballot, along with candidates from the
Libertarian, Green Party, etc. Without
a doubt, there were many who felt so disenfranchised and disgusted
with the Clinton or Trump choice that they didn't bother to vote –
or they entered a
protest vote for a
Libertarian, Green, or whatever candidate.
If ranked-choice
were available to all of us... [Disclaimer: don't know how many
choices would be allowed – let's assume max of 3 for the following
example]
Voter X might rank
choices:
- Bernie
- Clinton
- Trump
Voter Y might rank
choices:
- Green
- Bernie
- Libertarian
Voter Z might rank
choices:
- Trump
- Green
- Libertarian
Multiple rounds of
tallying votes could be tedious, but that's what computers are for.
You might already know how this works – if not, here's the general
idea.
First tally all the
#1 choices. Did any candidate get over 50% of the total? If yes, we
have a winner. If no, eliminate the last place candidate and count
again. For example, perhaps in the first round, after nobody got over
50%, the Green candidate is eliminated. In the second round, Voter Y
is now voting for Bernie. Eventually the “also ran” candidates
fall by the wayside and somebody (maybe Bernie) gets over 50%.
Today virtually no
3rd party candidate stands a chance of winning and a
“safe” protest vote (for a 3rd party candidate) can be
anything but safe. Let the people vote for who they want, without
having to worry about unintended consequences. Ranked-choice voting
seems like a fair way to decide an election and it might increase
voter interest and participation.
Of course the devil
is in the details... would need to have all the votes available and
ready (in electronic form) for automated tabulation by a deadline
before starting the elimination process, so the larger the amount of
data to collect the larger the challenge. And Americans, remarkably
short on patience, can't hardly wait for results. Also the two major
parties will never be enamored of the idea that a third party
candidate could actually breakup their established power structure.
Indeed, it often seems they're more interested in acquiring and
holding power than serving the greater good. Then again, screw the
establishment – it's our country and those who are elected are
there to serve our needs.
Just imagine if
ranked-choice were already in place. Bernie would've had a better
shot and the people would've had a better chance of getting what they
really want.
- Elimination of gerrymandering
Mapping of voting
districts should never be left to partisans. We need neutral and fair
folks to draw the voting districts. Fair maps let voters pick their
representatives, instead of letting representatives pick their
voters.
Iowa has already
done this – and every state, not just Wisconsin, should follow
their example.
- Reduction of big money influence
We seem to have
arrived at a place where the golden rule now reads, “whoever has
the gold makes the rules.” The power of big money is far too
influential in elections and calling the shots for how the laws
should be written and applied. Seems pretty simple to me:
- Money yields power
- “Power tends to corrupt and absolute power corrupts absolutely” - Lord Acton
The country is
becoming more of an oligarchy. If we want our democracy back, it
seems like reforming campaign finance laws is one place to start.
- Surely there are other ideas to restore the power to the people
I'm just one of many
who (to borrow a phrase) think the system is rigged.
In Wisconsin we have
a governor who is as likely to listen to these ideas as he is to
seriously consider advice from a pet hamster. And the Republican
majority is equally interested in any changes that might jeopardize
their hold on the reins of government. We can be sure they will do
their best to preserve or minimize changes to the severely
gerrymandered voting districts.
Don't know how to
change the culture of politics, but compromise now seems to be
considered a sign of weakness. The ruling party seems to take the
stance, “now is the time to force our agenda on everyone.”
Perhaps if elected
representatives weren't so safely ensconced (see gerrymandering) with
so little opposition (see ranked-choice voting) they would have to
consider more than their self-serving and parochial point of view.
We must resist and
push for reform.